Guardian: Fictional quote in CPS case likely generated by AI – second case in a year
A senior crown prosecutor at the UK's Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) presented an entirely fictitious court ruling to a court in a case about whether an 11-year-old boy should be prosecuted for rape.
A senior crown prosecutor at the UK's Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) presented an entirely fictitious court ruling to a court in a case about whether an 11-year-old boy should be prosecuted for rape. High Court documents seen by The Guardian show that the citation never existed – and that the prosecutor's explanation has been described as "unsatisfactory" by two senior High Court judges. The case is the second known instance of a CPS lawyer presenting non-existent legal authorities, likely caused by AI.
What Happened
According to the Guardian, High Court documents reported that Ravinder Dhillon, a senior crown prosecutor in the CPS's rape and serious sexual offences unit, presented a detailed citation to a case she called CPS – R v J [2024] EWCA Crim 3529. Dhillon argued in youth court that the boy should be prosecuted for the rape of his younger sister. The ruling turned out not to exist.
The Guardian writes that the paper's understanding is that the citation came from an AI-generated answer during an internet search. The paper presents this as its own sourcing, not as a confirmation from the CPS or the court. It is therefore not verified which AI tool or search engine, if any, was involved.
Dhillon's explanation for how the non-existent citation could have been relied upon has, according to the Guardian, been called "unsatisfactory" by two senior High Court judges and "a serious failing" by an expert on AI and law. The expert's identity is not given in the reporting.
The Timeline of the Case
The sequence of events, as described by the Guardian, is as follows:
- April: Dhillon made the decision to continue the prosecution against the boy. The decision was confirmed by a chief crown prosecutor.
- At her presentation in youth court: Dhillon presented the detailed citation to the non-existent ruling.
- October: Dhillon admitted that the fictitious citation was an error. She said she had actually intended to refer to an entirely different ruling – this time a real one – decided 15 years earlier.
- 3 November 2026: The Guardian published its exclusive report based on the High Court documents.
The High Court has, according to the Guardian, established that the CPS's reference to the fictitious citation did not affect the outcome of the boy's challenge to the decision to continue the prosecution. The trial against the boy is, according to the paper's reporting, set for youth court hearings in the same week as publication. The outcome of that trial is not known.
When It Happens Inside the CPS
A central dimension of the case is who made the error. The large wave of fictitious citations in UK courts has largely come from lay people representing themselves without a lawyer, who have taken legal authorities straight from AI answers. This case is different: the error was made by a senior crown prosecutor within the prosecution service itself – the main body for criminal prosecution in England and Wales.
According to the Guardian, this is only the second known case involving the CPS. In February, the organisation admitted that one of its lawyers, in an extradition case concerning two Romanians convicted of less serious offences, had referred to non-existent legal authorities – likely caused by AI. By that measure, the new case points to a pattern inside the organisation, not a one-off.
The Courts' Warnings and the CPS's Response
The case follows a clear warning from the courts. In June 2025, the High Court responded to AI hallucinations in cases spanning housing to banking by urging the Bar Council and the Law Society to consider measures to limit the problem "as a matter of urgency". In the same context, the Guardian reports, lawyers were warned they could risk sanctions, including contempt of court proceedings and referral to the police. The judge's warning was issued by Dame Victoria Sharp.
To the Guardian, the CPS said the organisation has a strict AI policy "which restricts its use so that it is not used to make legal decisions, and there must be human checks for accuracy". The CPS added that the error was discovered in connection with internet-based legal research, and that the organisation carried out an internal review.
It is worth noting the tension between the policy and the practice: even with a policy requiring human checks for accuracy, a fictitious citation ended up in a youth court case document – and stayed there through a process in which the decision to prosecute was made by a senior crown prosecutor and confirmed by a chief crown prosecutor. The CPS's full position, including whether the review covers other cases, does not fully emerge from the Guardian's reporting.
What Is Confirmed – and What Is Not
It is worth distinguishing between the established facts and what remains open:
Confirmed through court documents and Guardian reporting:
- That a detailed citation to CPS – R v J [2024] EWCA Crim 3529 was presented in youth court, and that the case does not exist.
- That Dhillon admitted the error in October and explained that she had meant a real ruling from 15 years earlier.
- That the High Court considers the citation did not affect the outcome of the challenge.
Not verified:
- The AI origin. The Guardian describes this as the paper's understanding, not as a finding by the CPS or the court. The specific tool has not been identified.
- Any sanctions against Dhillon or the CPS. None are confirmed.
- The outcome of the trial against the boy in youth court.
Why It Matters
The error had no consequences for the outcome of the challenge, according to the court, and that is an important point against overdramatising. But the case still strikes a vulnerable spot in the criminal justice system. Prosecution decisions against children – in this case an 11-year-old boy – rest on a chain of assessments in which the reliability of the legal basis is the very premise. When a detailed, false precedent can pass through both drafting and confirmation, it shows that human checks do not automatically catch AI-generated errors, even where policy requires them.
The second dimension is roles. Most known cases of fictitious citations in UK courts involve self-representing parties. When the same type of error has now been documented twice in a year inside the CPS – the chief prosecution authority itself – it shifts the problem from a question about inexperienced users to a question about how professional organisations verify AI-assisted research. This is the backdrop the courts drew with the June warning about sanctions, and it is the question the case now raises concretely: what actually happens when the checks fail yet again.
It remains to be seen whether the case has consequences for Dhillon or the CPS, and how the trial against the boy ends. Neither is known at the time of writing.

